Amy Caniglia
Owner Broker
Amy moved from Upstate New York to Colorado in 1994 with a BS in Marketing and Business Management. After living in the Vail Valley for 5 years, she made Park County her home.
She became a Realtor in 1999 and founded Caniglia Real Estate Group in 2005, the entire time focusing on the greater Alma/Fairplay area. Today, a dozen years later, Amy is trusted for her expertise, honesty and knowledge in the local real estate market.
Amy's LISTINGS
575 Witcher Lane, Fairplay $ 485,000
575 Witcher Lane, Fairplay
$ 485,000Cover all your bases with this 3 bedroom 2 bathroom MVP of a house! Overlooking the High School football/track complex…
564 Clark Street, Fairplay $ 539,000
564 Clark Street, Fairplay
$ 539,000Spacious, updated and move-in ready with all the charm and character that comes with circa 1880s architecture! 4 bedrooms +…
1313 Meadow Drive, Fairplay $ 55,000
1313 Meadow Drive, Fairplay
$ 55,000Nearly 1/2 acre on the edge of town with MOUNTAIN VIEWS and access to in-town amenities! PAVED ROADS, CITY WATER…
12950 Elkhorn Road, Como $ 169,900
12950 Elkhorn Road, Como
$ 169,900SOLD FOR $175,000! HUGE 35 acre parcel on well maintained county road! Mix of meadow, pine and aspen! Perfect for…
520 Front Street, Fairplay $ 265,000
520 Front Street, Fairplay
$ 265,000Prime Opportunity to Own Commercial Real Estate in a Growing Town! Fairplay’s sidewalk lined Front Street parallels the town’s Main…
236 Cheyenne Road, Alma $ 495,000
236 Cheyenne Road, Alma
$ 495,000Here is the cabin in the woods you’ve been looking for! Vintage Mid Century A-Frame on one side PLUS modern…
9619 County Road 18, Fairplay $ 1,200,000
9619 County Road 18, Fairplay
$ 1,200,000Retreat to this 88.09 acre sanctuary and unwind in style! You’ll find yourself basking in nature and your spectacular surroundings,…
555 Ponderosa Road, Alma $ 759,000
555 Ponderosa Road, Alma
$ 759,000Park like setting with MOUNTAIN VIEWS, PRIVACY AND WELL BUILT HOUSE! Wrap around deck! Fire mitigated property! Main level master…
223 Juniper Court, Fairplay $ 610,000
223 Juniper Court, Fairplay
$ 610,000SOLD FOR $640,000! FANTASTIC VIEWS of the Mosquito Range from this bright and sunny home! Soak in the views and…
53 Sunshine Loop, Fairplay $ 199,000
53 Sunshine Loop, Fairplay
$ 199,000BIG PRICE DROP!! Join the TINY HOUSE Movement! LIVE HERE FULL TIME! Or… it’s easy to rent if you’re looking…
190 Snyder Creek Road, Jefferson $ 475,000
190 Snyder Creek Road, Jefferson
$ 475,00074+ acres with stunning mountain views! Rustic feeling log cabin has electricity, domestic well (perfect for horses, livestock, greenhouse gardening,…
763 Bonell Drive, Fairplay $ 440,000
763 Bonell Drive, Fairplay
$ 440,000SOLD FOR $420,000! Imagine having all of the space you need under one roof! 4 Bathrooms, 4 Bedrooms PLUS 4…
232 Titmouse Drive, Alma $ 49,999
232 Titmouse Drive, Alma
$ 49,999BORDERS NATIONAL FOREST IN THE BACK and OVERLOOKS THE SOUTH PLATTE RIVER FROM THE FRONT! Plus HUGE, “in your face”…